Quantcast

Video of the Day

Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Alex Carnevale
(e-mail/tumblr/twitter)

Features Editor
Mia Nguyen
(e-mail)

Reviews Editor
Ethan Peterson

This Recording

is dedicated to the enjoyment of audio and visual stimuli. Please visit our archives where we have uncovered the true importance of nearly everything. Should you want to reach us, e-mail alex dot carnevale at gmail dot com, but don't tell the spam robots. Consider contacting us if you wish to use This Recording in your classroom or club setting. We have given several talks at local Rotarys that we feel went really well.

Pretty used to being with Gwyneth

Regrets that her mother did not smoke

Frank in all directions

Jean Cocteau and Jean Marais

Simply cannot go back to them

Roll your eyes at Samuel Beckett

John Gregory Dunne and Joan Didion

Metaphors with eyes

Life of Mary MacLane

Circle what it is you want

Not really talking about women, just Diane

Felicity's disguise

Live and Active Affiliates
This area does not yet contain any content.
Wednesday
May262010

« In Which We Fell One Of The Greats »

at his wedding

The Poet and the Dreamer

by KINGSLEY AMIS

Acquaintance with school examination scripts and with the tastes (or professed tastes) of young people entering the university will suggest that Keats is still the teacher's favourite poet. After all, Shakespeare, Milton, Wordsworth and the rest of the train require interpretation, textual or ideological: Keats can be read without a glossary and he believed simply in Beauty.

This immediacy of appeal is reinforced by the straightforwardly romantic subject-matter of the verse and by the engaging personality, tragic life and high aspirations of the poet; nobody, it seems unmistakable, was ever more of a poet than Keats. Most adolescents of any sensitivity will respond with an enthusiasm they may still recall when, bloody but unbowed after their struggles with pass degree, diploma, appointments board and head teacher, they in their turn face the task of implanting tolerance for poetry in the twelve-year old mind.

kingsley with first wife hilly
Any favourable attitude towards any verse must be better than none, and yet the results of an early inoculation with Keats may prove an obstacle to further literary development. If Keats is to be the ideal poet, ideal poetry too readily becomes a tissue of affectionate descriptions of nice things interrupted by occasional complaints that the real world is insufficiently productive of those nice things, and if any pupil should wonder what the dales of Arcardy have got to do with him, then the answer is that poetry deals with 'the world of the imagination', i.e. not with the real world.

Those who undertake to break down such a preconception are likely to suffer from conscience trouble. Is it worth the risk of removing one enjoyment and not managing to substitute a 'better'? Might it not be safer to push the chaps on with their Keats and with the poems that can, with whatever distortion, be assimilated to Keats: 'Christabel', 'Oenone', Paradise Lost (first two books only, of course), snippets from The Faerie Queene?

A rational reading of Keats, whatever the long-term result, is initially destructive. An uneasy suspicion of this is discernible even at the height of the cult in the late nineteenth century. Sidney Colvin, noting a 'dissonance' - or, more accurately, a piece of poetical fudging - in the 'Ode to a Grecian Urn,' remarks consolingly that 'it is a dissonance which the attentive reader can easily reconcile for himself: and none but an attentive reader will notice it.' The attentive reader will have little time for Colvin's book, the recent reissue of which, seventy years after its first publication, motivates some depression.

Kingsley and Hilary in the mid-1950s with, from left, Sally, Philip and Martin.
One imagines it already winging its way to the shelves of school libraries, where its adulatory portraiture and innocent assertion of its subject's greatness will inspire another legion of essays maundering about the way 'the poetry seems to throb in every line with the life of imagination and beauty' in that sugary erotic extravaganza 'The Eve of St Agnes'.

Even in his best poems Keats devotes himself too uncritically to 'the world of the imagination.' Even the 'Ode to the Nightingale', though containing passages which must delight the most jaded, is full of frigidities, of appeals to the remote and merely fanciful. What else are the references to hemlock, Lethe, the Dryad (tautologously described as 'of the trees'), Flora, the blushful Hippocrene (seen as a kind of Greek red sparkling Burgundy, and apparently sedimented at that, Bacchus and his pards (brought in to effect a translation into poetese of the unpoetical notion of getting drunk)?

Such entities are, as Jeffrey observed of the subject of 'Hyperion', 'too far removed from all the sources of human interest.' And to string together counters of this kind, to use 'Olympus' faded hierarchy' as correlatives for what are evidently the most passionate feelings, was a favourite procedure with Keats, as can be seen at a glance at the 'Ode to Psyche' or the 'Ode on Melancholy.'

Poetry was for Keats a matter of 'O Poesy', of Apollo, the Muses and inspired bards. This connects with his attitude to the actual business of writing. According Robert Graves (I cannot track this anecdote), Keats used to dress up in poetic robes and laurel crown to encourage the afflatus. And if Apollo did come through on the line with a personal call, the divine message was not to be tampered with; poetry must come as naturally as leaves to the tree. Keats was too intelligent to believe this all the time, but when he revised his verse at all the task was always scamped and he never became a conscientious craftsman. Shoddily worked sonnets would be thrown off and dispatched to friends the same day, to reappear unaltered in print; he knew Endymion needed radical rewriting, but 'I am tired of it' and 'it is not in my nature to fumble' — in other words, to take undue trouble.

martin amis, elizabeth jane howard and kingsley Endymion, as the Quarterly Review soon pointed out, was scattered with awkwardnesses forced upon, or rather suggested to, the poet by the exigencies of rhyme. Such faults reappear throughout the whole of Keats' work, partly because of his habit of selecting forms that require several rhymes to the same sound.

with john lennon

These forms were chosen capriciously, without regard to their appropriateness or to his own capacities, on occasion merely because they happened to be used by poets he happened to admire. It was only an admiration for Paradise Lost  that eventually took him to blank verse, where common sense might have taken him before 1818. Even the Odes, written for once in original stanza forms, are disfigured by Endymion-like crudities: the 'deceiving elf' of the 'Nightingale', for instance, an incarnation into which 'the Fancy' is recklessly crammed to save having to fumble with the rhyming line, and the two analogous defects of the first stanza - 'emptied...to the drains' (sc. not 'poured down the drain' but 'drained, drunk off') retained to rhyme with 'pains', and 'melodious plot' (so glaringly inappropriate, with its connections with cultivation) retained to rhyme with 'happy lot.'

It is the middle stanzas of the poems — I take it as fairly representing the mature Keats — that its merit chiefly lies, in the unforgettable entrancing picture of the wood itself, and in the poet's confession, of an unwonted sobriety in style, that he finds himself 'half in love with easeful Death.' Here, by chance, there are no technical flaws, and here too, of set purpose, the classical lumber is stowed away.

That English strain which Dr. Leavis rightly notes as a characteristic of Keats at his finest comes to the fore. In addition, the poet is talking about himself, not a Delphic simulacrum of himself, and has something to say about human existence, not a wish-fulfilling caricature of it. But it is only here, and in the induction of the revised 'Hyperion', that Keats fulfilled for more than a line or two his often-made promise to treat of 'the agonies, the strife of human hearts', to become one of those 'to whom the miseries of the world are misery, and will not let them rest.'

To exalt into greatness one whose achievement was actually that of an often delightful, if often awkward, decorative poet may have, as was suggested above, harmful consequences. Any presumption that Keats might in time have become a major artist is cast in doubt by the fact that it is unpromising theories about poetry that derive from defects of character, quite as much as bad influences and the results of illness, which vitiate his existing work.

kingsley photographed by fay godwin
The kind of writer he might have become is indicated in his letters:

Imagine the worst dog-kennel you ever saw, placed upon two poles from a mouldy fencing. In such a wretched thing sat a squalid old woman, squat like an ape half-starved from a scarcity of biscuit in its passage from Madagascar to the Cape, with a pipe in her mouth and looking out with a round-eyed, skinny-lidded inanity, with a sort of horizontal idiotic movement of her hand: squat and lean she sat, and puffed out the smoke, while two ragged, tattered girls carried her along. What a thing would be a history of her life and sensations!

But that was not the kind of subject that 'a glorious denizen' of Poesy's wide heaven could undertake.

POSTSCRIPT 1970:

This now strikes me as a rather clever undergraduate essay (pretty good, that is to say, compared with most of the undergraduate essays I remember). I would not want to withdraw or mitigate any of the nasty remarks about Keats' technical shortcomings and their connection with a self-indulgence deeply embedded in his mind and heart, and to this day I find it genuinely curious that anybody should have written (as M.R. Ridley did) a whole volume called Keats' Craftsmanship: surely a candidate for that shortest-books series along with Canadian Wit and Humour, Great Marxist Humanitarians, and The Vein of Humility in D.H. Lawrence.

However, I neglected to celebrate, or took for granted, that tremendous originality and audaciousness which were far beyond any mere 'decorative' quality and, by making poetry personal, so to speak democratized it. When Keats opened the Nightingale ode by writing, 'My heart aches', he was writing about his own heart and nobody else's. Earlier poems in the first person had had the name of some other character invisibly prefixed to them, normally an idealized or anyway carefully trimmed version of the poet, often, indeed, the Poet, which figure does a good deal of talking in Wordsworth's anecdotal and autobiographical verse. Keats' ability to cut through all that — an ability that must have sprung from the same root as his self-indulgence — made it possible for anybody at all to identify with him in the process of reading the poem.

The results of that 'democratization', like others, may not have been altogether happy, but like them, they were inevitable. Whatever the detail of Keats' performance, this achievement is such that no one who has never thought him the greatest poet in the world, no matter for how brief a period, has any real feeling for literature.

Kingsley Amis died in 1995. He is the author of over twenty novels.

with young Martin Amis

"Summer Begs" - Sarah Jaffe (mp3)

"Pretender" - Sarah Jaffe (mp3)

"Vulnerable" - Sarah Jaffe (mp3)

"Better Than Nothing" - Sarah Jaffe (mp3)

References (40)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    In what he later called “a rather clever undergraduate essay,” Kingsley Amis argues that Keats was not a great poet, just “an often delightful, if often awkward, decorative [one].”
  • Response
    In Which We Fell One Of The Greats - Home - This Recording
  • Response
    In Which We Fell One Of The Greats - Home - This Recording
  • Response
    Response: balding treatment
    In Which We Fell One Of The Greats - Home - This Recording
  • Response
    In Which We Fell One Of The Greats - Home - This Recording
  • Response
    In Which We Fell One Of The Greats - Home - This Recording
  • Response
    In Which We Fell One Of The Greats - Home - This Recording
  • Response
    In Which We Fell One Of The Greats - Home - This Recording
  • Response
    Response: Cartier Bracelets
    In Which We Fell One Of The Greats - Home - This Recording
  • Response
    Response: otc viagra
  • Response
    Response: vigaplus
  • Response
    Response: Wilma Trant
    I found a great...
  • Response
    Response: Jackie Surran
    I found a great...
  • Response
    Response: smart device
    I found a great...
  • Response
    I found a great...
  • Response
    Response: Sirena Lanski
    I found a great...
  • Response
    I found a great...
  • Response
    I found a great...
  • Response
    Response: galini
    I found a great...
  • Response
    Response: doom
    I found a great...
  • Response
    I found a great...
  • Response
    I found a great...
  • Response
    Response: Hong Rossbach
    I found a great...
  • Response
    Response: Amee Krips
    I found a great...
  • Response
    Response: Roselyn Conlan
    I found a great...
  • Response
    Response: Corine Barresi
    I found a great...
  • Response
    Response: Bob Belsey
    I found a great...
  • Response
  • Response
    Response: Matthew Midyett
    I found a great...
  • Response
    I found a great...
  • Response
    I found a great...
  • Response
    Response: si jelek
    I found a great...
  • Response
    I found a great...
  • Response
    Response: Cheryl Shandley
    I found a great...
  • Response
    Response: Eduardo Bomar
    I found a great...
  • Response
    Response: Lamar Abdula
    I found a great...
  • Response
    I found a great...
  • Response
    I found a great...
  • Response
    In Which We Fell One Of The
  • Response
    In Which We Fell One Of The

Reader Comments (15)

What an idiotic essay. But it is to be expected from Kingsley Amis - the man was a talentless little philistine.

September 29, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterAv

Thanks for this wonderful site. I really like the way you emphasized your point of view right here.


fat burning workout

December 22, 2010 | Unregistered Commenterfat burning workout

Pick up your favorite ed hardy clothing and show off the attractiveness of ed hardy. The ed hardy uk mainly deals with the ed hardy shirts, ed hardy t-shirts and other branch products like ed hardy case and ed hardy iphone. Besides, I bet you will surely enjoy the famous brand of ed hardy bags and ed hardy jeans. Or if you are interested, the ed hardy shoes and ed hardy hoodies are also of exquisite style that you will fall in love with. The ed hardy shop will definitely be your first choice for fashion and price. If you are seeking for quality and inexpensive ed hardy, ed hardy uk is the place that you will never miss out!

December 30, 2010 | Unregistered Commentered hardy uk

Ed hardy brand has been listed since there are many people's attention,Louboutin very popular in recent years.

January 6, 2011 | Unregistered Commentered hardy clothing

We will stay away from winter, spring is approaching. Imagining that you are wearing jimmy choo shoes in the summer, that is a wonderful thing, jimmy choo has always been the best shoes for girls, very sexy, very beautiful, jimmy shoes meke you become beautiful , your feet will feel very comfortable, jimmy choo online sell all kinds of jimmy choo shoes, I hope you'll like it.jimmy choo sale well in UK! Many people like christian louboutin pumps , most of them are young people , if you are Middle-aged , christian louboutin boots will make you young .ysl shoes are for women ,you can get a 85% off ,you can save a great number of money ,yves shoes as well as ysl shoes.
louboutin sale, louboutin shoes uk !

January 10, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterchristian louboutin

air force one shoes.Air Jordan Sneakers.buy air jordans online.Buy Jordan 1 shoes.new jordan shoes.Cheap Nike Dunk Kicks.wholesale jordan shoes.Authentic Jordan 13 Shoes.air force 1.Rare JordansMichael Jordan Shoes.cheap jordans.Jordan Retro Shoes.newest air jordans.Retro Air Jordan 18.new jordans.Jordan Retro Sneakers.Authentic nike shoes.Discount Basketball Shoes.cheap air force ones.Discount Air Jordan 21.jordan sneakers.Retro Jordan Shoes.original air jordans.Cheap Jordan Sneakers.authentic jordan shoes.Wholesale Nike Air Jordans.air force.Cheap Air Jordan 23 for sale.all jordan shoes.Discount Air Jordan 22.custom air force ones.Air Jordan Shoes.air jordans for girls.Retro Jordan Shoes.authentic retro air jordans.Authentic sneakers.jordan retro shoes.authentic products.air jordans kicks.Michael Jordan 2009.all air jordans.Authentic Retro Jordans Shoes.cheap authentic air jordans.Retro Jordan Shoes.air force 1 shoes.discount jordans.Air Jordan Flight 45.jordan true flight.Air Jordan Shoes.amazing basketball shoes.retro jordans.Nike Sneakers.100 authentic air jordans.sneakers way.kids jordan shoes.cheap Jordan Spizike for sale.exclusive air jordans.Wholesale Jordans.air force shoes.Jordan L'Style One.Custom Jordans.jordan release dates.nike air jordan shoes.jordan 1.Nike Air Force 1 Low.buy jordan shoes.jordan 12.hottest jordan shoes.retro air jordans for sale.Cheap Jordan Shoes.baby jordan shoes.hottest jordan shoes.amman jordan.Retro Air Max 90.flights to jordan.new jordans.Nike Shox NZ shoes.exclusive kicks.jordan 5.Shopping sites.Shox R4 shoes.authentic air jordans for sale.Cheap Air Jordans.jordan 23.nike jordan kicks.Nike Dunk Low.cheap kicks online.nike shoes kicks.jordan 11.Air Jordans.jordan 13.nike sb blazer low.geek shoes.nike dunk shoes offers.wholesale jordans.Wholesale Jordan Shoes.authentic jordans.authentic jordan shoes.cheap kids jordans.buy jordan shoes.authentic jordans.kids jordan shoes.cheap nike shox.jordan shoes release dates.deckers ugg boots.custom jordan shoes.Jumpman23.rare jordans.jordan 23 shoes.air jordan.jordan shoe websites.Ugg Boots Sale.cheap nike dunks.baby jordan shoes.classic crochet ugg boots.cheap michael jordan shoes.cheap real jordans.jordan sneakers.air jordan shoes.cheap air jordans.cheap nike running shoes.jordan shoes pictures.authentic ugg boots sale.buy jordan shoes online.cheap nike dunks.cheap jordan sneakers.nike.real jordan shoes.cheap jordans.kids ugg boots.cheap jordan basketball shoes.wholesale jordans.jordan shoes for girls.authentic jordan sites.jordan tennis shoes.cheap nikes.jordan shoe stores.sheepskin ugg boots.wholesale air jordans.cheap dunks.jordan 11 shoes.cheap jordan shoes.michael jordan basketball shoes.wholesale nike shoes.jordan.ugg boots wholesale.authentic jordan shoes for sale.cheap air force ones.cheap real jordan shoes.authentic jordan sites.mens jordan shoes.cheap air force ones.michael jordan shoes for sale.ugg boots clothing.cheap authentic jordan shoes.air jordans.china wholesale jordan shoes.cheap shoes.cheap jordans.Cheap Supra Shoesjordan 13 shoes.air force.

February 7, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterair jordan retro 11

gianmarco lorenzi shoescollection new style arrival, you must be attracted by the colorful shoes at the first sight. When people talked about gianmarco lorenzi pumps, you may think about the double-up platform, rhinestone studded on the vamp,gianmarco lorenzi crystal pumps stiletto high heels. But this season gianmarco

colorful summer, gianmarco lorenzi knockoffsthese shoes are made of fuschia color, pink, blue, apricot, red satin and suede materials. gianmarco lorenzi replica feet and ankle

fastening. With about 5 inches stiletto high heels, can make you more confident and charming. You must be the focus of the crowd with these gianmarco lorenzi shoes.
These gianmarco lorenzi crystal platform pump are sold well at our gianmarco lorenzi gregory shoes . And now we have a great promotion:
If your order reach up to $399 (pay by Credit Card or PayPal),can choose a pair of shoes as present ).
We provide high quality replica online, all free shipping worldwide,fake gianmarco lorenzi And we accept return and exchange, if you do not get your package,gianmarco lorenzi heels we will refund your money back. Welcome all of you to shop for cheap at our onlinecheap gianmarco lorenzi store.

May 29, 2011 | Unregistered Commentergianmarcolorenzis

WATCHES TO ¡°KILT¡± FOR...
For the 7th annual "Dressed to replica watch Kilt" charity fashion show in replica Breitling watches New York, celebrities and athletes replica Cartier watches again discarded their pants replica Hublot big bang in favor of kilts and other Scottish replica IWC watches designs. The event, whose replica Omega watches proceeds this year benefit wounded replica Patek Philippe watches war veterans, featured a replica Panerai watches Mad for Scotland theme. But for iW, it seems as though the event's theme drew some notable watch enthusiast celebrities and would have been replica Tag Heuer watches more aptly titled ¡°Mad about Watches¡±!
The replica Vacheron Constantin watches host of this year¡¯s Dressed replica watch to Kilt was our favorite James watch for sale Bond actor, Sean Connery. Since Breitling Aeromarine replica James Bond is known for Breitling Bentley replica high-tech and stylish gadgets, it's not Breitling Chronomat replica surprising that he has long replica Cartier watches been associated with well-known watches replica Hublot watches . During Connery¡¯s Bond reign, a Rolex graced replica IWC watches his fictional character¡¯s wrist in three Omega Seamaster replica separate movies: ¡°Dr.No¡± (Rolex Submariner on a crocodile strap), ¡°Goldfinger¡± (Rolex Submariner Omega Speedmaster replica on a NATO issue two-tone green diver strap), and Panerai Luminor replica ¡°Never Say Never Again.¡±
No doubt Rolex daytona replica the watch made an impression beyond Rolex day-date replica the film set as Connery is known for wearing Tag Heuer Carrera replica a Rolex off camera, too.
Walking the runway in a replica Vacheron Constanti watches stylish blue kilt was NBC ¡°Today Show¡± weather replica Patek Philippe watches anchor A1 Roker. According to our cheap nike shoes Celebrity Magnet, the svelte A1 Roker ¡°wore Rolex daytona replica a kilt like no other weatherman I mbt walk shoes know!¡± Roker wears a black Rolex Submariner.
Also donning Rolex submariner replica a kilt on the run-way was ¡°The Good omega speedmaster watch Wife¡± television star Alan Cumming, who wears lovers sneakers a Diesel Badass Chrono. Looks like mens fashion watches cumming is taking his cues from his Tourbillon mechanical watch character, Eli Gold-a smart-talking image Chronogragh sport watches consultant.
The third celebrity our Celbrity nike air force 1 Magnet attracted was Olympic speed skater Shani Rolex seadweller replica Davis, who skated down the runway ladies quartz watch. On Shani¡¯s wrist was an Avenir nike air max Chrono, a savvy timepiece loaned to him by the nike dunk shoes new Italian watch brand.
When asked about his silicone watch preference in watches, Shanisaid Rolex masterpiece replica that he was ¡°more of a beads guy than a Rolex airking replica watch guy,¡± to which our Celebrity Magnet omega seamaster watch responded, ¡°Well, beads don¡¯t really Rolex yachtmaster replica tell you the time!¡±
Ann

May 30, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterAnn

Welcome to Our cheapest tibia gp,cheapest tibia gold Store
We are professional provider of virtual currency and power leveling of your characters ! We have tibia money,tibia gold, tibia leveling,tibia account,tibia item Services. Special offers for you ever-ever-ever-ever-yday here From US !
Want tibia money,tibia gold,tibia gp?
Just Buy tibia gold,tibia money,tibia gp now !

You'v got a right place to buy cheap guild wars gold, (Also said as gw gold/guild wars 2 money,guild wars 2 armor,guild wars 2 platinum, guild wars 2 farming) in all gw campaign (nightfall, Prophecies, Factions). We also have gw ectos,gw keys and gw obsidian shardson sale.

Here is the best place for the Runescape players to buy runescape gp & cheap rs2 gold. We are the professional website for runescape money & cheap rs2 gold selling. We just offer the lowest price to buy runescape gold and the best service.At the same time,we also sell runescape item and runescape account
We are 24/7 online, if you have any problems with buying runescape gp, you can contact us anytime and we will try our best to solve your problems.

June 7, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterzdy

Amanda is aWholesalewonderful placePromotional Productsfor shopping you can findApparel & Fashion Accessorieseverything you really want to buyBags & Hatsbelieve us is equal to believe yourselfDrinkwareto be honest is our big promiseKey Chainsthe goods is not only popular but alsoMore Promotional Productsgood qualityNovelty Productsthe style is the newest and nice lookingPromotional Pensto buy the newest good and the best quality goodsUSB Flash Drivesplease come hereNow your chance comingChina Wholesalebest good and newest goods have put on the shelfPromotional Productslook and searchApparel & Fashion Accessoriesit must have the goodBags & Hatsyou want to buy nowDrinkwareit is free to lookKey Chainsfinding the good you lackMore Promotional Productsis worth anythingNovelty Productsto be patiencePromotional Penstake your time to look our goodUSB Flash Drivesit must not be missed

June 7, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterWholesale
nice job vre!
February 10, 2012 | Unregistered Commentervpills
nice tube terty.
February 10, 2012 | Unregistered Commenterpanax
they in their turn face the task of implanting tolerance for poetry in the twelve-year old mind.
June 6, 2012 | Unregistered Commentervibram five fingers

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.